Mani vs. Madhi: Which Discharged Fluid Requires Ghusl?

Maintaining physical and spiritual purity from major ritual impurities is a fundamental pillar for every Muslim before performing the obligatory prayers. One of the most frequent dilemmas that arise within the community is the confusion surrounding the discharge of fluids from the private parts. The recurring question is: Does every fluid that is discharged necessitate a major ritual bath?

To resolve this issue, we must possess a foundational understanding of the comprehensive concept of purification (thaharah) grounded in authoritative Islamic jurisprudence literature. This article provides an in-depth analysis of the characteristics of semen and the crucial difference between mani vs. madhi. We will rely on the classic text Asna al-Matalib Sharh Rawd al-Talib (Volume 1, Pages 64-65) authored by the esteemed Shafi’i scholar, Shaykh al-Islam Zakariyya al-Ansari.

The Ruling on Genital Discharges: Is Ghusl Mandatory?

Not every fluid discharged from the human reproductive organs obligates an individual to purify themselves using pure, absolute water (air mutlak) through a major ritual bath (ghusl). Islamic law meticulously differentiates these fluids and their respective legal consequences, a topic universally discussed in the discourse on the causes of ghusl in Shafi’i fiqh. Based on the text of Asna al-Matalib, the specific factor that definitively establishes the state of janabah (major impurity) is the emission of semen (mani).

الأمر الثاني خروج المني أي مني الشخص نفسه الخارج أول مرة من رجل أو امرأة (ولو بعد غسل) من جنابة

Shaykh al-Islam explains: “The second matter is the emission of mani, meaning the person’s own mani that exits for the first time, whether from a man or a woman, (even if after bathing) from janabah.”

This ruling is firmly based on the authentic hadith narrated by Imam Muslim: “Indeed, water (the obligation to bathe) is due to water (semen).” There is also a narration from Umm Salamah when Umm Sulaym asked the Messenger of Allah ﷺ whether a woman is obliged to perform ghusl if she experiences a wet dream (ihtilam). He ﷺ decisively replied: “Yes, if she sees the fluid (semen).”

The 3 Primary Characteristics of Mani in the Shafi’i School

Frequently, an individual may feel uncertain when trying to identify the type of fluid they have encountered. To alleviate this confusion, Islamic scholars have formulated highly precise parameters. Shaykh al-Islam Zakariyya al-Ansari delineates three primary characteristics to correctly identify semen (mani):

قوله: (ويعرف) المني (بتدفق)… (أو تلذذ) بخروجه… (أو ريح طلع أو عجين رطبا و) ريح (بياض بيض يابسا)

If even one of the following three characteristics is met, the fluid is legally judged to be mani:

• 1. Exiting in a Spurting Manner (Tadaffuq): Mani generally exits the private part in a spurting or pulsing rhythm (tadaffuq), rather than merely dripping slowly and passively. This aligns with the word of Allah in the Quran (Surah At-Tariq, verse 6), which describes the nature of semen as ma’in dafiq (a spurting fluid).
• 2. Accompanied by Intense Pleasure (Taladhdhudh): The emission of mani is consistently accompanied by the peak sensation of sexual pleasure (taladhdhudh). Following the discharge, the body or the reproductive organ typically responds with a state of relaxation or languor (futur).
• 3. Possessing a Distinct Odor (Wet and Dry): If a person does not experience the spurting sensation or the pleasure (for instance, if the fluid is discharged while they are deeply asleep), this third characteristic becomes the primary determinant. When the fluid is still wet (ratban), its odor resembles the smell of bread dough (‘ajin) or date palm pollen (tala’). However, once the fluid has dried on clothing (yabisan), its scent changes to resemble the smell of dried egg whites (bayad bayd).

Do Women Also Discharge Mani?

A common misconception among the lay public is that mani (semen/seminal fluid) is exclusively produced by men. From both a jurisprudential (fiqh) and biological standpoint, this assumption is incorrect. Fiqh texts specifically assert that women also discharge mani possessing identifiable characteristics. This is entirely distinct from menstrual blood, which requires a specific obligatory bath for menstruation.

وعلم من كلامه أن المرأة كالرجل في أن منيها يعرف بالخواص المذكورة

The text above confirms: “And it is known from his statement that a woman is like a man in that her mani is recognized by the aforementioned characteristics.”

Furthermore, Shaykh al-Islam clarifies that the color and viscosity of the fluid cannot be used as absolute benchmarks:

قوله: (ولا أثر لثخانة ولون) وغيرهما من صفات المني فالثخانة والبياض في مني الرجل والرقة والاصفرار في مني المرأة في حال اعتدال الطبع فعدمها لا ينفيه ووجودها لا يقتضيه

This signifies that the thickness and color do not affect the legal ruling. Under normal, healthy conditions, a man’s mani does tend to be thick and white, whereas a woman’s mani tends to be thin and yellowish (ar-riqqah wal isfirar). The absence of this specific color or thickness does not negate its status as mani, and conversely, its presence does not absolutely mandate it.

Mani vs. Madhi: A Guide to Overcoming Doubt

Madhi (pre-seminal fluid) is a clear, sticky fluid that typically exits at the onset of sexual arousal (for example, during foreplay, or simply thinking or imagining something arousing), without being followed by physical languor. Madhi is legally impure (najis) and nullifies the ablution (wudu), but it does not require a major ritual bath (ghusl).

So, what should one do if they discover a dried fluid on their clothing and are overcome by doubt (shakk)—is it mani vs. madhi? The Shafi’i school provides an incredibly practical and non-burdensome resolution for the Muslim community:

قوله: (كمن شك هل الخارج من ذكره مني أو مذي) فإنه يخير بينهما (ويعمل بمقتضى اختياره) فإن جعله منيا اغتسل أو مذيا توضأ وغسل ما أصابه

If a person is in doubt, they are given a choice (yukhayyar). They must then act according to the consequences of their chosen assumption:

• If they choose to consider it mani, they are obligated to perfectly execute the complete procedure of the obligatory bath.
• Conversely, if they choose to consider it madhi, it is sufficient for them to simply perform wudu and thoroughly wash the affected body parts and clothing. This legal provision is specifically designed to liberate a worshipper from excessive, obsessive doubts (waswas) in practicing their religion.

Comparison Table of Genital Fluids

The following is a concise guide to clarify the distinction between mani and madhi:

Conclusion

Understanding the difference between mani vs. madhi is the key to ensuring the daily validity of our acts of worship. Unlike communal guidelines such as the procedures for washing a deceased body according to fiqh, which is a communal obligation (fard kifayah), ensuring one’s personal purity from major impurities due to the emission of semen is an individual obligation (fard ‘ayn) for every Muslim. If the discharged fluid meets just one of the three criteria—spurting, accompanying pleasure, or a distinct odor—then it is mani that obligates ghusl. However, if the discharge occurs solely due to initial arousal without these specific traits, it is madhi, which simply requires washing the area and repeating wudu.

FAQ on Genital Fluids in Fiqh

Bagikan Kajian: